Tiger Tiger Burning Bright

Stuff about football & community & belonging

  • Home
    • About TTBB
    • Michael Kelleher Collection
    • Other Stuff We Like
      • Redbubble Club
    • Guests
    • Contact Us
  • A Man In The Outer
    • Tiger, Tiger archive
  • Tassie Tiger
    • Archive
    • Tiger Tube
    • Tasmanian Tigers Museum
  • Tiger Abroad
    • A Tiger Abroad (archive)
  • Virtual Duffle Coat
  • The Benny
  • The Maureen
  • The TTBB Shop

Round 7 v Western Bulldogs at the MCG

06/05/2021 By Brendan O'Reilly Leave a Comment

We don’t have a great record against the Dogs. We beat them last year which impressed me, but lost in 2017 and 2019. They are one of several teams whom we often struggle against, even when we are travelling a lot better than they are. Right now they are on six wins and on top of the ladder. We have won three and lost three and you could say that our season hangs in the balance. That might be a slight exaggeration, but you could still say it and plenty of pundits are.
Embed from Getty Images

We don’t have a great record against the Dogs. We beat them last year which impressed me, but lost in 2017 and 2019.  They are one of several teams whom we often struggle against, even when we are travelling a lot better than they are.  Right now they are on six wins and on top of the ladder.  We have won three and lost three and you could say that our season hangs in the balance.  That might be a slight exaggeration, but you could still say it and plenty of pundits are.

I can’t get a ticket without paying a lot for an average seat and so I don’t go and I don’t feel bad about that. And with the children out doing their own thing it’s just my partner and me at home.  She suggests In the Line of Duty and I think that sounds good.  I’ll tape the footy and if we get smashed I won’t even have to watch it.

First Quarter

In any case, I get to see the first quarter before she gets home and it doesn’t look great.  In fact, it looks a like our game against Melbourne – long stretches of fruitless Richmond dominance, good opportunities wasted, followed by bursts of counter-attack from the Dogs where they kick a goal.  If it keeps going like this we’ll get “dashed” as my daughter once put it.

The Tigers begin well, winning the first clearance and getting the ball in quickly to Riewoldt who takes a good mark, turns and kicks it into Lynch who gets hands to it but can’t take the grab.  Broad and others defend well against the fist Doggies attack and after three minutes Lynch marks Short’s thoughtful kick deep in the pocket.  He kicks a good point on the near side.

Collier-Dawkins wins a free, his first kick in AFL, on the forward flank.  He sends it in quite quickly but we can’t take a grab.  Baker is already very busy on the forward line.  Riewoldt flies but can’t hold it, Eastern-Wood has the ball forever and loses it in the tackle but there’s no free.  The Dogs rebound and Scott snaps and goals from a tight angle.  It’s 1.1 to our single point, after five minutes of Richmond domination.

Lynch marks 80m out and kicks it to a Bulldog.  But he keeps trying, takes another very good mark and passes Collier-Dawkins 48m out.  The young feller dishes off to Short who kicks long and misses.  He should have let the young feller do that by himself.

Nankervis makes a huge tackle on Bailey Dale.  No doubt about the Tigers’ intent, but can they bring their skill? Lynch marks and misses from 50 out on a 45 angle.

Balta kicks a bomb into Lynch who marks beautifully for the fifth time and misses from 25 metres.

Mitch Hannan misses a shot that’s almost as easy which must make Lynch feel better.  Broad is playing very well again and clears the ball well from deep in the back line.  

Embed from Getty Images

Bruce marks strongly and goals and it’s 2.3 to 0.4.  Naughton marks with nobody near him and the Dogs have three and we don’t have any.  The Dogs’ handballs are lightning fast and for all our effort their rebounds are slick and damaging.  Our defence is starting to crack too and Grimes’ clearing kick goes straight to Bruce who fires it back quickly.  The moment is saved with good defending from Mansell or Collier-Dawkins, I can’t tell which, and a fairly blatant rushed behind from Grimes who gets away with it.

Lynch is having a terrible night.  Well, not quite as bad as against Melbourne where he seemed to go missing, but he can’t hit the side of large house with the footy.

Embed from Getty Images

But for all his woes he doesn’t give up.  He marks Bolton’s kick on the edge of the goal-square and after a series of elaborate hand-signals that would have been visible from low-Earth orbit he dishes off a handball rather than take the set shot.   Aarts receives it and is nearly taken down by two Doggie’s defenders.  But he still kicks the goal and all is not lost.

Lynch has taken seven marks and kicked three points.

Quarter-time score:  Richmond 1.4 to Bulldogs 3.6

At this time we begin watching In the Line of Duty and I feel good about the decision. Why inflict misery upon yourself?  We watch three episodes and by the time I switch back to the footy the song is being sung and the smiling captain is being interviewed.  Luckily, I have set the tape and I make it a late night by going back to the second quarter and watching through to the end.

Second Quarter

The quarter starts badly when Bailey Smith takes a brave mark from McIntosh’s hurried kick and goals from 50.  We are 20 points down.  Riewoldt takes a soaring mark 60 out and kicks in quickly to Lynch who can’t mark.  The Doggie’s clear it again.  Toby takes a strong pack mark, on the half-back flank, kicks it to Shedda who kicks to Bolton who goes on a little run, gets around an opponent and fires in a perfect pass to Aarts 25 out who misses.

We’re not playing badly though.  Balta takes a great intercept mark and we move the ball well upfield, Lynch kicks perfectly to Riewoldt whose kick is disappointing.  Bolton is grabbed without the footy and seconds later doesn’t quite hold the mark of the year.  There is quite a period of Tiger domination but no goals to show for it. Pickett has a good chance and misses.  The Dogs rebound in seconds and Naughton marks and goals and we’re 25 points down.

Rioli handpasses to Lynch who misses and we’re 1.7 to 5.7.  At least we’ve caught up on the behinds.

Lynch kicks another point.  With a minute and a half left we finally kick a goal. Cotch takes a brave mark going back with the flight, he passes to Graham who scoops it up, runs in and kicks to the square.  Bolton roves the crumb and bangs it through from two metres out and we can all breath again.  It’s 2.8 to 5.8 – our second goal in almost a half of footy.

With 20 seconds left Bontempelli wins a free for falling over and misses from 20 out.

Embed from Getty Images

Half-time score: Richmond 2.8 to Bulldogs 5.9

Third Quarter

Balta thwarts another Dog attack. He is having a very good game, as is Baker who seems to be in everything.   He goes for a beautiful run at half-forward and sends it to Riewoldt laces out who marks and goals from about 45.  This move began with Bolton who found Baker with precision and vision.

Embed from Getty Images

With about five minutes gone Treloar kicks high and not terribly long out of defence.  McIntosh marks with courage and gives it to Baker who takes his time and kicks long, low and straight to Lynch who marks right in front, five metres out.  Bakers’ poise and pass were perfect and Lynch goals at last and we’re right back in it.  Who ever doubted that we could be?  It’s 4.8 to 5.9.

Baker tackles Keath and brings him to earth but BT calls this as “Baker is run over by Keath.” In the words of Chris Rees, this man oozes misinformation.  The fact that Keath is clearly taller and heavier than Baker might also be worthy of comment.

Graham roves the subsequent ball-up, snaps and goals and we’re only a point behind.  The ball has scarcely been out of our forward line for five minutes.

Bolton kicks a point from long range and scores are level.  Baker is tackling everyone, the bigger they are the harder he tackles.  The Dogs go for 20 minutes without a possession forward of the centre.  Houli wins a lucky free for high contact and kicks it long to Lynch who marks 25 out.  He goes back and kicks it and we’re in front and Lynch’s kicking problems are behind him.  It’s all happened very quickly and there are still 11 minutes left in the quarter.

Embed from Getty Images

With six minutes left the inside-50s are 16 to zero for the quarter and we’re seven points up.  Shortly after that the Dogs get forward which is disappointing but was bound to happen.  Naughton marks and goals and we’re only a point in front.  

With three and a half left Lynch marks and goals from 45 out on a 45 angle and he’s got three for the quarter.

The Doggies attack and very nearly goal but some desperate, and, by the commentators, completely un-remarked defence, turns it into a point. The little things that these well-paid footy watchers miss is astounding.

The siren sounds as Collier-Dawkins is running towards the 50 with the ball in his hands.

Three-quarter-time score:  Richmond 7.10 to the Bulldogs 6.10

Final Quarter

For about five minutes there are a few points but no goals and the Tigers hold onto their one-goal lead.  The umpiring isn’t bad, but it does seem a bit lax.  You know this is true when you start saying out loud “That should have been a Bulldogs free kick for high contact”.  I find myself saying this quite a lot, but this is easier to say when the result is known.

After five and a half minutes Richmond find space on the wing, Ross sends a long bomb into the square, Baker pounces on the crumb and goals from five yards out and we’re two goals up.  The kick from Ross was a sixty-metre monster, sent in quickly and bound to trouble the defence.

Embed from Getty Images

Bontempelli marks on a tight angle after the ball seems to have gone out of bounds.  He passes to Shache who goals from right in front and we’re back to a one-goal lead with 12 minutes left.

With the ball on our half-forward flank the Dogs look set to break away after a chain of quick handballs until Baker lays a huge tackle on Lapinksi and throws him out of bounds.  Baker is one of the smallest players in the AFL, so unless he’s tackling Caleb Daniel, he’s always taking on someone bigger.  This impresses me but the Seven commentators are unmoved.

Lipinski has a chance to level the scores, runs in and hits the post.  Tigers by five points.

Richmond attack and Castagna passes to Houli who marks 45 out, takes a few breaths, walks in and goals from the 50 as the Dogs kindly had nobody on the goal-line.  The ball went over the pack and bounced across. Thank you Doggies.  It’s Houli’s first goal for two years.

Embed from Getty Images

There are seven minutes left and we’re 11 points up.

With five minutes left Bolton nearly pulls down mark of the year, again, this time with one hand.  From the boundary throw-in Lynch grabs the footy, handballs to Bolton who dances through traffic and goals and we’re 17 points up.

Embed from Getty Images Embed from Getty Images

The dogs have a chance to pull one back when Naughton marks on a strong lead but from 40 out he wins Worst Kick of the Past Ten Years Award and the Tigers clear the footy.

Cotch goes off and puts the trackie top on and Naish gets a run for the last few minutes.  Going by their thick, dark hair this is what’s known as a “like-for-like” substitution.  It’s a good sub too.  Naish chases Hunter who has taken two bounces and is then tackled just as he gets a handball away.  The tackle means the ball doesn’t go where it’s meant to and Richmond win the footy back.  It goes to Naish who passes to Bolton who marks directly in front.

Naish is hugged by his team-mates for his never-give-up effort.  Bolton goals and the game is over, we’re 22 points up with 90 seconds left.

Final Score: Richmond 11.11.77 to the Bulldogs 7.13.55

It’s been a huge second half.  Our best players have been, well, the whole team really.  But the standouts for me are Bolton, Balta, Broad and Baker, mainly for alliterative purposes.  Also really good are Cotchin, Houli, Grimes, Graham, Astbury, Ross…it really was the whole team who lifted.  As usual I forgot Toby.  He was magnificent.  And the fact that it is always very hard to pick our best few players is something I love dearly about our Tigers.

Embed from Getty Images

Brendan O'Reilly 06/05/2021Filed Under: benny, front

Round 6 v Melbourne at the MCG

29/04/2021 By Brendan O'Reilly 1 Comment

I haven’t been to the footy since we flogged the Giants in the Grand Final in 2019. Mum was still alive then and we chatted on the phone in the long hours before the first bounce and she left me a voicemail at the end of the game saying she thought we’d played pretty well. She didn’t have her own team but liked her children’s teams to win. I still have that voicemail on my phone.
Embed from Getty Images

Anzac Eve, 24 April 2021

I haven’t been to the footy since we flogged the Giants in the Grand Final in 2019.  Mum was still alive then and we chatted on the phone in the long hours before the first bounce and she left me a voicemail at the end of the game saying she thought we’d played pretty well.  She didn’t have her own team but liked her children’s teams to win.  I still have that voicemail on my phone.

The build-up is good, the minute’s silence, the Last Post.  The silence in particular is really good, we need more moments like that.  As the solemnities end and the loud, crappy music fills the void I realise that I’ve forgotten to set the tape.  So my notes will have to be good.

The loud music reminds me of something that I felt a lot of last year – relief.  I didn’t have to think about going or not going to the footy.  I didn’t have to endure this crap at the game I love.  Still, there was a downside to the global pandemic and I mustn’t forget that.

Embed from Getty Images

The game starts well for us.  Melbourne’s first attack goes out on the full.  Richmond rebound and Shedda kicks a point.  Petracca tackles Dusty and pushes him out of bounds and wins a free.  Then we get another point before Riewoldt soccers a brilliant goal. Toby wins a free for deliberate out of bounds and his kick manages to hit both goal posts but only one behind is registered.  This seems unfair, although no doubt within the letter of the rules.

Riewoldt gets another and we’re looking all right.  Cotchin sets up Graham for a likely goal but his kick falls short.  Salem gets a point for the Dees, then they get another one and then a goal which is followed by an embarrassing light show, the whole stadium bathed in red and blue.  Wow, I’m so impressed.  This would make me come to the footy again.  I feel in my bones that at the next RFC home game I go to I’ll have to suffer through the same thing, but worse, as it will be our club shaming itself in lights.

Shedda, who is playing well, bravely marks a clearing kick and goals from 30 out.  But Melbourne are looking better and their Pickett kicks well to Fritsch who marks and goals.  The light show again makes me long for lock-down.  The quarter ends and the spruiker reminds us that we’re at the footy, tells us which teams are playing and what the score is.  I’m so grateful to him.  Contested possessions are 39 each.

Quarter time score:  Melbourne 2.2 to Richmond 3.3

Embed from Getty Images

Although we’ve paid $45 each to sit in the top deck of the Olympic Stands – not bad seats at all, really, but 20 rows from the front – the bays either side of the Richmond Cheer Squad at the City End are almost empty.  I do not understand the AFL at all.

The scoreboard tells me that Short has had 8 touches and I’ve barely noticed him.  That says more about me than him.  But it’s a big ground with a big cast and it’s easy to miss things.

There is light rain at the break and we’re glad we’re under cover.  The game restarts and Lambert misses with a set shot.  Bolton seems to be very busy and our Pickett misses from 48.  We are attacking a lot but can’t kick a goal. Short concedes a deliberate out-of-bounds from a good way out and Neale-Bullen kicks a very good goal.  The quarter is half-gone and we lead by a point.  Tom McDonald takes a strong mark and goals from 45 out on a tight angle and the Dees are in front.

Shedda misses from 40 after taking a mark and McDonald kicks another and the Dees are up by 11.  They are using the ball better than us and their attacking moves are holding together while ours come unstuck.  The Dees get another, making it five in a row and they lead by 17. Dusty has been very quiet and so are our supporters.

Half-time score:  Melbourne 6.6.42 to Richmond 3.7.25

Early in the third Melbourne attack and an outnumbered Pickett almost pulls off a miraculous spoil.  But he doesn’t and we’re 23 down.  And then five goals down and I’m comparing us to Adelaide in the third quarter in the 2017 Grand Final.  We just don’t know what to do.  Nothing we try to do seems to work and Melbourne have the ball on a string.

Embed from Getty Images

After 14 minutes Shedda kicks our first goal in about an hour of footy.  Our last five minutes have been good.  Our pressure has lifted and we could still do this. But we need another one or two before the last break.

Melbourne attack again. Pickett is again outnumbered and again nearly manages to pull off a great spoil but he gets Neal-Bullen high who goals from close range and we’re five goals down again.  We respond well with one of our best moves of the night.  Graham kicks into the 50, Toby handpasses to Aarts who goals.

But the Dees have all the answers and Tom McDonald marks almost on the goal line and it’s 30 points once more.  They’ve matched our pressure and are killing us in execution.  Well, of course they are.

Broad, who is playing well, kicks into the 50 and Shai takes a great mark and kicks a point from 30 out.  It’s not our night.

Three-quarter time score:  Melbourne 10.8 to Richmond 5.8

Embed from Getty Images

I don’t think we can win from here but we could at least make it hard for them.  My great wish is that the Dees don’t just walk away with it.

My wish is granted, more or less.  We lose by 34 points, meaning the last quarter was close, at least.  We kick 1.4 to 2.2 for the quarter.  Petracca seals the win in the first minute putting us six goals down. People are talking about him being the next Dusty and tonight he is.  Our Dusty has not been seen since the main break and we have to assume he is injured. But the scoreboard and our phones tell us nothing.

Aarts takes a good mark from Cotchin’s kick but misses from 25 metres.  Broad and Baker continue to play well.  Lynch kicks out on the full.  He’s had a bad night, but he’s not alone.  I’m beginning to worry that we’ll lose by a lot.  Their Pickett kicks a point and we rebound and Lynch kicks a point.  Finally Shai gets one after Lynch passes to him.  We’re down 29 points and 13 minutes have gone.  In the wet that is a mountain to climb.

Bolton takes another mark and kicks a point from 25 out on a tight angle.  As seems to happen when we lose to Melbourne on Anzac Eve, there is an altercation on the Melbourne forward line which leads to a down-field free to their Pickett who goals from 25 out.  The Dees supporters go nuts and there’s a second free, of course, before the ball is bounced.  Luckily Oliver misses this one from 30 out.

I just want us to kick one goal so that we win the quarter but we don’t get it.  Bolton has a chance but misses the lot.  At last the siren goes and we’ve only lost by 34 points.  And it’s only Melbourne, which doesn’t hurt half so much as losing to Collingwood and it’s only April, it’s not like a prelim final.

Final score:  Melbourne 12.10.82 to Richmond 6.12.48

Embed from Getty Images

Still, it hurts.  We’re mortal after all.  Dusty had been written up in The Age this very morning for his indestructability.  He’s barely been injured in a dozen seasons.  But he’s injured now all right.

Not time to panic though.  We lost to Geelong by 12 goals in the middle of 2019 and looked like a non-finals team.

Best players for us had names starting with B – Baker, Broad, Bolton. Also Short might have played well but I kept not noticing him.  Toby played well too, although from our high seats I may have mixed him up sometimes with Balta.  Between them they played all right. Shedda too, he kept us in it for a good while.

Easy game against the Dogs this Friday night.

On Sunday night I drop my phone in the water while doing the dishes and listening to a podcast about the AIDS Angel of Arkansas.

Brendan O'Reilly 29/04/2021Filed Under: benny, front

Round 3 v Hawthorn at the MCG

25/06/2020 By Brendan O'Reilly 1 Comment

My daughter’s soccer training has resumed on Thursday nights. Where once she trained in the afternoon at the end of our street, she now she trains at night in the Deep North of Reservoir at a ground named, I am told, after Trent Cotchin’s father.
Embed from Getty Images

Thursday 18 June 2020

My daughter’s soccer training has resumed on Thursday nights.  Where once she trained in the afternoon at the end of our street, she now she trains at night in the Deep North of Reservoir at a ground named, I am told, after Trent Cotchin’s father.

This is not all bad.  I have plenty of time to call my Mum and only miss a bit of the start on the radio.  But by then Richmond are doing badly and it only gets worse.  Later I re-watch the first quarter just so I can record it for posterity.

There is no Dusty but we’ve won without him before and I’m not worried.  At the start of the game the players and umpires gather in the middle and take a knee in solidarity with their brothers and sisters for racial justice and then the game starts for real.  There is fake crowd noise leading up to the first bounce and this is quite extraordinary.  This was the most notable loss of atmosphere in the pre-pandemic AFL – the spine-tingling crescendo of crowd noise as the first bounce approached.  Well, the AFL destroyed that years ago and now it’s back, only it’s fake.  The lesson seems to be, you can have anything these days, so long as it’s not real.  I don’t want to think about that too much.

Rioli’s hair is a worry.   Its’ far too short and we all know what happened to Bontempelli and to Samson when their long locks were shorn.  Richmond are good in the first few minutes.  Prestia attempts a long-range soccered goal which goes out on the full.  Does his grin afterward suggest he can’t take this crowd-less game seriously?  Then Shai Bolton misses from right in front.  The Hawks rebound quickly and Vlaustin gives away a free to Gunston who kicks it.  I whinge about the umpiring, but it was there and we’d have taken it if it had gone to us.

Hawthorn attack again and force a turnover as Richmond try to clear.  Wingard out-marks Stack, plays on and goals and it’s two goals to one point.  We attack but the Hawks win a 50 and in no time Breust kicks another.  Richmond can’t get anything going.  Kicks go straight to Hawthorn players, the Hawks attack again and O’Meara goals.  It’s four goals to none and the short quarter is barely half over.  Among other things I hate, I hate how Hawthorn have a player called Hardwick.  It’s not right.

Riewoldt takes a good mark on the flank but his kick is marked by one of the four Hawk defenders it falls to.  Pickett kicks it straight to McEvoy and clearly some basic instructions need to go out to our boys.  With 16 seconds left Ceglar tackles Stack and wins a free right in front, and the fake fans make quite a racket.

Quarter time score:  Hawthorn 5.1.33 to Richmond 0.1.1

Embed from Getty Images

Richmond make some progress after this, but in the end it’s the first quarter that kills us.  We lost that by 32 points and we lost the game by 32.  In the last term we actually threaten to make an unlikely comeback. But our set shots are abysmal.  Lynch’s miss from the top of the goal-square is the worst but he has plenty of mates.  Bad kicking is bad footy and we’ve been outplayed all night.

Final score:  Hawthorn 11.6.71 to Richmond 5.9.39

Embed from Getty Images

Vlaustin might be our best player.  Our four Jacks don’t do much.  I wonder how hard it is for Richmond, in particular, to play in front of no crowd.  Our players and our coach always thanked our fans for their noise and passion.  It can’t be easy when that’s taken away and in an even competition every little edge counts.

Embed from Getty Images

Next Saturday we play the Saints at Docklands which will be even more soul-less than usual.  I would like to say I’m looking forward to it, but I’m not.

Benny Votes

Vlastuin 5, Grimes 4, Short 3, Cotchin 2, Castagna 1

Leaderboard
5: Higgins, Vlastuin, Cotchin
4: Soldo, Grimes
3: Short
2: Houli
1: Lynch, Castagna


Blair Hartley Appreciation Award: for players who have joined Richmond from another club
(Eligible 2020: Caddy, Grigg, Houli, Lynch, Nankervis and Prestia)

Houli 2, Lynch 1


Anthony Banik Best First Year Player:for anyone who was yet to debut before round 1
(Eligible 2020: Collier-Dawkins, Dow, Turner, English, Martyn, Cumberland, Aarts, Ralphsmith, Nyuon, Miller)

No votes yet


Joel Bowden’s Golden Left Boot:for left footers
(Eligible 2020: Chol, Nankervis and Houli)

Houli 2


Greg Tivendale Rookie List Medal:
upgraded from the rookie list during the current season

(Eligible 2020: Aarts, Baker, Chol, Eggmolesse-Smith, Stack and Pickett)


Maurice Rioli Grip of Death Trophy:
For the Tiges top tackler in 2020

Soldo 15
Pickett 11
Cotchin, Prestia 10
Bolton 9

Brendan O'Reilly 25/06/2020Filed Under: benny, front, Uncategorized

Round 2 v Collingwood at the MCG

16/06/2020 By Brendan O'Reilly 1 Comment

It had taken me very little time to accept that there would be no footy in 2020. In the teeth of a global pandemic that would cause our health system to collapse, losing a season of footy seemed a small thing. And once crowds were out, well footy was out. I’ve long argued the point that our game, at the top level, is not about the great mark or the long kick. It’s about the crowd. Take out the crowd and you might have a pretty spectacle but you won’t have any drama.

Embed from Getty Images

Thursday June 11 2020

It had taken me very little time to accept that there would be no footy in 2020.  In the teeth of a global pandemic that would cause our health system to collapse, losing a season of footy seemed a small thing.  And once crowds were out, well footy was out.  I’ve long argued the point that our game, at the top level, is not about the great mark or the long kick. It’s about the crowd.  Take out the crowd and you might have a pretty spectacle but you won’t have any drama.

Consequently, I was a non-believer in round 1.  Just declare the season over, I said, and give the flag to us.  Everyone knew we were going to win again.  It follows from this that I have watched with some dread and misgiving as the AFL pushed and shoved and prodded and poked until its 2020 season came back to life.

Anyway, back to life it came and back to the ‘G go our boys and the Pies.  One good thing about there being no crowd – there is no agonising on this cold Thursday night about going or not going – the couch or the outer?  That decision was made for us.  So, onto the couch we go.

Embed from Getty Images

Before the match all the players take a knee in solidarity with their brothers and sisters of colour and the injustices meted out to them by police and others.  It’s a moving sight and I’m proud of all of them.

In no time though I’m nostalgic for the early days of the pandemic, when tens of thousands of lives were at stake and our civilisation faced possible ruin.  At least we didn’t have football to endure.  And how I have not missed that sick feeling of dread as the Pies take control of the game and our boys look like they don’t know what they’re doing.

Embed from Getty Images

The big trouble with Collingwood is that they have an awful lot of very good players.  If truth be told, more skilful players than us.  Grundy, who is forever monstrous for that last-second goal that sank us in round 2 2016 – and which foretold our season quite accurately – is bigger and better than ever.  De Goey is simply terrifying – he’s like Dusty but can take a high mark and possibly kick the ball further.  Luckily, he seems to lack Dusty’s consistency.

Embed from Getty Images

Anyway, the Pies get the first goal and the second and then a third.  After 20 minutes I leave the couch and I miss Collingwood’s fourth.  My family are having a GoTo meeting in the wake of my Mum breaking her wrist.  This is a very pleasant diversion.  Mum appears cheerful and is now out of hospital and my brother is with her in Wodonga.  After half an hour or so I get back to the couch and things have improved slightly.  Tom Lynch has kicked three in a quarter but we’re still 14 points down at half time.

Half time score:  Collingwood 5.3.33 to Richmond 3.1.19

The second half is easier to watch than the first quarter but that’s not saying a lot.  We edge closer with a goal and then just before the last break Higgins marks a missed shot for goal.  Everyone assumes it has gone through for a point before he’s marked it but there’s a score review and the result is “no score”, a mark instead to young Jack.  Of course, he goes back and bananas it through for a goal and we’re only two points down.

Embed from Getty Images

The last quarter is very old fashioned – like, 1858-old fashioned.  We kick four points and Collingwood kick two.  I actually enjoy it as it’s pretty exciting and the fake crowd noise is amusing.  Then we level the scores right near the end and I think we could sneak another and win it but instead Collingwood bring the ball down-field with much of their usual skill and I cry out, “We’ll take the draw!  We’ll take the draw!”  The ball goes out for a throw-in deep in their forward line with a handful – a Grundy handful you could say – of seconds left.  But the Tigers manage to smother it again and the siren goes and it’s all over and we’ve taken two points off our dreaded enemies.

Embed from Getty Images

Wayne Carey says “Nobody likes draws” and I say, “No, nobody likes you Wayne.”  Honestly.  Not one player or coach or club official is heard to say “I’d rather they’d beaten us, I’d feel so much better.”  No, and no supporters say that either.  How could you?  I’d rather die of thirst than have half a glass?  Nobody says that.

But everyone agrees it has been a very strange night.  Footy might be back but it’s a zombie version that we recognise, but barely.  I note with interest that there is no music blaring during the post-match interviews, nor at the breaks.  This proves my long-argued point – the music blares out to drown out the crowd.  If there’s no crowd, there’s no need for the music.

Jack Higgins might not be our best player on the night but he’s the best story.  He says after the game that he came close to very serious brain damage after his two operations.  To be playing footy again is a miracle and something to celebrate.

Full time score:  Collingwood 5.6.36 to Richmond 5.6.36

Editor’s note: There was no round 1 match report or Benny votes because I think all of us at TTBB didn’t feel the season should go ahead, and it was a terribly flat game in the end. But here we are now, footy is happening, and at some point we will duck back and assign some votes to Round 1 as well.

Embed from Getty Images

Benny Votes

Higgins 5, Soldo 4, Cotchin 3, Houli 2, Lynch 1


Blair Hartley Appreciation Award: for players who have joined Richmond from another club
(Eligible 2020: Caddy, Grigg, Houli, Lynch, Nankervis and Prestia)

Houli 2, Lynch 1


Anthony Banik Best First Year Player:for anyone who was yet to debut before round 1
(Eligible 2020: Collier-Dawkins, Dow, Turner, English, Martyn, Cumberland, Aarts, Ralphsmith, Nyuon, Miller)
No votes yet


Joel Bowden’s Golden Left Boot:for left footers
(Eligible 2020: Chol, Nankervis and Houli)

Houli 2


Greg Tivendale Rookie List Medal:
upgraded from the rookie list during the current season

(Eligible 2020: Aarts, Baker, Chol, Eggmolesse-Smith, Stack and Pickett)
No votes yet


Maurice Rioli Grip of Death Trophy:
For the Tiges top tackler in 2020

Soldo 12
Prestia 10
Pickett 9
Martin, Bolton 8

Embed from Getty Images

Brendan O'Reilly 16/06/2020Filed Under: benny, front

AFLW r5 v Greater Western Sydney at Robertson Oval, Wagga Wagga

09/03/2020 By Brendan O'Reilly 3 Comments

I have missed all of our AFLW matches since round 1 which isn’t good and our team still haven’t won a game which isn’t good either.  On the other hand, at least I haven’t missed our first win in this competition. This match isn’t on the telly but the streaming over the internet thingy works surprisingly well.  For the first half I’m getting dinner ready as I watch but for the second half I plug the laptop into the telly and enjoy – if that’s the word – the game from the couch.

5.10pm Saturday 7 March 2020

Embed from Getty Images

I have missed all of our AFLW matches since round 1 which isn’t good and our team still haven’t won a game which isn’t good either.  On the other hand, at least I haven’t missed our first win in this competition.

This match isn’t on the telly but the streaming over the internet thingy works surprisingly well.  For the first half I’m getting dinner ready as I watch but for the second half I plug the laptop into the telly and enjoy – if that’s the word – the game from the couch.

Our first quarter is pretty good.  After the Giants get the first goal Conti makes a great run through the middle, kicks long from outside 50 and the ball is gathered and kicked through the big sticks by Bernardi and there’s only two points in it.  But not too long after that Privitelli gets away from her several Tiger defenders to mark and goal.  I don’t think much of it at the time, but it sets a pattern of sleepy defending that will hurt us badly.

Quarter time score:  GWS 2.5.17 to Richmond 1.1.7

Embed from Getty Images

The Giants are clearly the better team in the second term but miss lots of chances.  Stahl takes a very brave mark in the middle of the ground for us and Monahan clears well from defence a couple of times but there seems to be little system to our game and passes rarely find a team-mate.  At the main break only the Giants’ poor kicking for goal is keeping us in it.

Half-time score:  GWS 3.8.26 to Richmond 1.2.8

Embed from Getty Images

The Giants keep missing in the third term, but it seems that even their points will be enough to beat us.  Beeson hits the post after marking Privitelli’s pass very easily and then Barr misses from right in front.  Grace Campbell defends bravely for the Tigers and wins a free but the siege of our backline continues and the inside-50 count is 21 to 10 for the afternoon.

From a stoppage the Giants’ Irish giant Staunton storms through and kicks another goal.  Privitelli takes another very good mark and hits the post.  Richmond attack a couple of times but can’t find the big sticks either.  Frederick takes a big mark 55 out but Conti can’t hold her kick into the 50 and nothing comes of it.  Frederick marks again, runs into the forward line and kicks a point and at the last break it’s the Giants by 28.

Three-quarter-time score:  GWS 4.13.37 to Richmond 1.3.9

Embed from Getty Images

Phoebe Monahan is moved into the middle in the last quarter which might be a good move.  We need something to change, that’s for sure.  On the other hand, we probably miss her in the back-line and the Giant’s pile on the damage in the last.  After Bernardi kicks another point from a set shot Staunton marks again, plays on again and kicks her third.

Frederick hits the behind post and the Giants attack again.  Staunton marks and plays on, yet again and goals and it seems as if nobody wants to tackle her.

Hannah Burchell for the Tigers wins a holding-the-ball free for a very good tackle, but her kick falls short.  Monahan snaps and misses.  There’s a big scuffle near the bench, the Giants are awarded a 50 and Staunton marks yet again.  Privitelli marks her kick and scores from the tight angle with seven seconds left.  The siren is a great relief.  It’s the Giants’ highest ever AFLW score and their biggest ever winning margin.

Summary

Not a lot of joy for the Tigers this afternoon.  The effort and ferocity which were a real feature of our game in round one seem to have lessened and a more skilful and experienced team like the Giants can then do much as they please. This seems especially so in the last quarter when the Giants buried us.

Embed from Getty Images

Best players for Richmond:  Conti, Monahan, Bernardi, Frederick.  Grace Campbell also showed some skill and bravery and Kate Dempsey showed promise in her first AFLW match.

The Maureen for best player
5 votes – Monica Conti
4 votes – Phoebe Monahan
3 votes – Christina Bernardi
2 votes – Sabrina Frederick
1 votes – Grace Campbell 

Leaderboard
20 Monahan
18 Conti
10 Campbell
8 Bernardi
6 Wakefield
4 Makur Chuot, Frederick
2 Brennan, Edmonds
1 Stahl

The Kate Sheahan Shield for players recruited with AFLW experience [eligible: Burchall, Bailey, Tesoreiro, Frederick, Bernardi, Conti, Whitford, Ross, Makur Chuot, Monahan]
20 Monahan
18 Conti
8 Bernardi
4 Makur Chuot, Frederick
2 Brennan

The Peggy O’Neal Claret Jug for best AFLW first year player [eligible: everyone else not in above list]
10 Campbell
6 Wakefield
2 Edmonds

The Kate Dixon Grip of Death for our top tackler
25 – Conti, Jacques,
22 – Campbell
21 – Sansonetti
17 – Woodward
16 – Brennan
14 – Molan, Monahan

Embed from Getty Images

Brendan O'Reilly 09/03/2020Filed Under: front, maureen, Uncategorized

AFLW r1 v Carlton at Princes Park

16/02/2020 By Brendan O'Reilly Leave a Comment

I had planned to leave work early but I’ve been behind with things since I got back from leave three weeks ago and in the end I catch the 4.19 from Eltham.  Among other things that have gone awry this year, my bike was stolen from a locked cage at work two weeks ago and it now takes longer to get home than it used to.  I have a very strong feeling that if we’re not at the ground when the gates open at six, we won’t get in at all.  And even if we do get there at six, maybe we still won’t get in.
Embed from Getty Images

I had planned to leave work early but I’ve been behind with things since I got back from leave three weeks ago and in the end I catch the 4.19 from Eltham.  Among other things that have gone awry this year, my bike was stolen from a locked cage at work two weeks ago and it now takes longer to get home than it used to.  I have a very strong feeling that if we’re not at the ground when the gates open at six, we won’t get in at all.  And even if we do get there at six, maybe we still won’t get in.

It is Richmond’s first ever AFLW game, after all.

Both my daughters are coming and I think it’s the first time the three of us have been to the footy together since the Elimination Final in 2015.  My younger daughter barracks for North and so all three of us went to that game.  Whatever happens tonight, we will be happier than we were on that blighted, sunny afternoon.  Not even the North daughter was happy that day – “You two were just so sad that I was sad too.”

Embed from Getty Images

It’s close to six before we leave the house, so we definitely won’t be there when the gates open.  But as it happens, we’re in good time.  There is no queue – and still no admission charge – to get in and we find good seats at ground level.  Despite its newness and the small suburban grounds it is played on, AFLW is cursed like the men’s game with corporate noise.  We position ourselves between two speakers – they have one every fifty feet or so – and while the spruiking and loud music bother us, we know that it can’t be any quieter anywhere else.

By chance we find my niece, Terri, sitting nearby and she is soon joined by her Melbourne Uni footy mates.  We fill in the time before the first bounce in the normal way – eating hot chips, chatting idly, trying to memorise players’ numbers.

The latter is a tough exercise but before the game starts, I have in my mind no.34, Makur Chuot, 3 Katie Brennan, 4 Monique Conti and 7 Lauren Tesoriero.

Soon after the game starts no.2, Phoebe Monahan, is added to this list.  She seems to be playing at full back and our defenders have their hands full.  Carlton are kicking to the end we’re sitting near and we see far too much of the footy.

Carlton score first with a point from a set shot and more missed shots and rushed behinds follow, all to Carlton, who lead 5-0.  I’m glad it’s not soccer.  Then Carlton get their first goal after Loynes wins a free for being held.  

Embed from Getty Images

The Tigers defend ferociously, however.  The tackling, smothering, chasing and bumping is constant and nothing is easy for the Blues forwards.  Phoebe Monahan is especially good for us.  Razor Ray Chamberlain is umpiring and even he has to give us the odd free for holding the ball.  But by quarter time he is clearly in the running for some sort of equal-opportunity award – he is as biased against our Women’s team as he is against the Men’s.

Yet even allowing for the umpiring, the Blues seem to have an edge over us.  The ball rarely leaves their forward line and they have an infuriating habit of passing the ball to their team-mates who then pass it to another team-mate.  We struggle in this area and many of our hard-earned kicks are turned over.

Embed from Getty Images

Quarter time score:  Richmond 0.0 to Carlton 1.5

The second quarter goes a lot like the first, only we see less of the action as Carlton are attacking the other end.  But our attack seems to be getting somewhere until a promising move is turned back by a free kick for deliberate out-of-bounds.  As if.  Soon after that we have our first ever AFLW score when someone kicks a point.  We all cheer loudly.  Carlton rebound and soon have that point back.  Then they get another point to go further in front.  The Tigers attack again for a point and are threatening again when the siren goes.  Of course.

Half-time score:  Richmond 0.2 to Carlton 1.8

Our Gabby Seymour (28) takes a great mark in defence early in the quarter before Chamberlain gifts Carlton another shot on goal.  Courtney Wakefield, our number 8, marks but misses everything from quite an angle.  Carlton string some more passes together – how do they get away with it? – and kick another goal and it’s 3.8 to 0.2.

Embed from Getty Images Embed from Getty Images

Darcy Vescio – who is still “Our Darcy” as she used to play for the Falcons at the bottom of our street – snaps but misses, luckily for us.  But Carlton soon after win a 50, Harris marks in the goal-square and it’s 4.9 to 0.2.  Yet another free to the Blues leads to another goal and at the last break it doesn’t look great for us, 5.9 to two points.

It must be said at this point that whenever Carlton kick a goal the electronic scoreboard bursts with a loud and obnoxious noise.  It really would be a terrible thing if AFLW matches were ruined by having some crowd atmosphere.  The powers that be are right onto it.

Three-quarter time score:  Richmond 0.2 to Carlton 5.9

In the last quarter the Tigers are kicking to our end again.  The ball is kicked long into our forward line, Sabrina Frederick takes a great mark and could it happen that we kick our first ever AFLW goal?  Yes it can!  Yes she does!  And we erupt and we’re all chanting and cheering and all is right with the world.

Embed from Getty Images

Carlton immediately reply but nobody cares.

The Tigers attack again, Wakefield keeps her feet in the traffic, weaves this way and that and goals and we erupt again.  It’s been a tough night for the Tigers but they’ve never given up and have kicked two snags in the last term. And in fact, we’ve won the last quarter, which is the Richmond way.

It’s been a tough debut for our team but they can hold their heads high.  Their tackling and chasing and attack on the footy have wanted for nothing.  Even with Razor Ray at his worst they’ve won countless frees for holding the footy.  But their kicking has let them down a bit and there have been some heart-breaking turnovers.

Carlton, on the other hand, showed how they made the Grand Final last year.  But we’ll be better next week and the week after that.

And Footy’s back and we have an AFLW team now and all is good with the world.

Best players for me included Monahan and Makur Chuot who defended tirelessly and Wakefield and Frederick for taking their rare chances.

Embed from Getty Images

The Maureen for best player
5 votes – Phoebe Monahan
4 votes – Akec Makur Chuot
3 votes – Christina Bernardi
2 votes – Courtney Wakefield
1 vote – Sabrina Frederick

The Kate Sheahan Shield for players recruited with AFLW experience [eligible: Burchall, Bailey, Tesoreiro, Frederick, Bernardi, Conti, Whitford, Ross, Makur Chuot]
5 Monahan
4 Makur Chuot
3 Bernardi
1 Frederick

The Peggy O’Neal Claret Jug for best AFLW first year player [eligible: everyone else not in above list]
2 Courtney Wakefield

The Kate Dixon Grip of Death for our top tackler
10 Sarah Sansonetti
8 Alana Woodward, Phoebe Monahan
7 Kodi Jaques

Brendan O'Reilly 16/02/2020Filed Under: front, maureen

2019 AFL Grand Final Match Report

01/10/2019 By Brendan O'Reilly 7 Comments

This, as always, is a personal account of the match.  As you know by now it was a win for the ages by our Tigers, but this report won’t end the way you want it to.  Sadly, our day didn’t end the way we wanted it to and I can’t pretend otherwise.

▰▰▰▰▰▰▰

This begins like a close Grand Final with a long period of massive pressure by both sides.  I think of Sydney v West Coast in 2005 when nobody scored for hours.  GWS attack from the centre bounce but Broad takes the first mark of the match and send them back.  Riewoldt takes an excellent mark at the other end but it’s not paid.

Caddy kicks long and it’s knocked through for a point.  The Giants win a holding-the-ball free against Dusty in the goal-square.  When he gets up, he seems to have a problem with his eye.  Cotch makes a massive tackle against Mumford in the middle of the ground but somehow the Giant wins the free.  There’s a solid chant of “bullshit…bullshit…” but on the telly you can see that Presty sort-of elbowed him in the face well after he was tackled.  I’m worried that we’ve dominated for four minutes and have no goals to show for it.

Embed from Getty Images

There’s plenty to whinge and worry about.  But why whinge and boo when you could just get behind your team?  I haven’t spent days chasing tickets and two hours waiting at the gate and five hours in here before the game to stand here in silence.  And so I get the whole bay going with “Richmond!  Richmond!” and that’s all it takes and we’re all chanting our lungs out.

Mumford tackles Caddy and returns the facial contact.  “A little bit of unfriendly behaviour…it’s good to see isn’t it?” says Brian Taylor, clearly wanting to cement his grip on Boofhead of the Year Award.  

Castagna runs onto a good chance but misses and we have three points for our trouble.  The Giants attack and Pickett gets his first touch.  We can’t clear the ball and eventually the Giants get their first point.  Half the quarter has gone and it’s 0.3 to 0.1.  Pickett gets a handball on the backline, Shedda wins a free and we can clear the footy.  But then Greene marks, on an angle.  He kicks from the 50 but misses, which is a great relief.

The thought of him running rampant and kicking six goals has kept me awake at night.

With only four minutes left the quarter Cameron out-marks Grimes and kicks it from 55.  He’d better not kick too many more of them.

But we get another attack going after Lambert makes a great tackle in the middle. Advantage is paid and Martin out-marks Shaw, plays on and goals and we roar with relief.  Soldo has a chance for a mark right in front but misses it.  There’s a boundary throw-in and he grabs the footy and loses it but no free is paid against him.  Pickett gets the ball to Rioli who gathers and kicks from the 50 and the siren sounds as it splits the big sticks and our relief is great.

Embed from Getty Images

At quarter time a big, older bloke, already quite drunk, says I must give him my name and he’ll put me on Facebook “Because I think you’re great.”  My team are winning the GF at quarter time, my daughter and I are here to watch it and an old drunk bloke is telling me I’m great.

Quarter time score:  Richmond 2.5.17 to GWS 1.2.8

▰▰▰▰▰▰▰

Riewoldt wins a lucky free for a push and kicks the goal.  From the centre bounce Soldo gets it to Pickett who takes our collective breath away with a blind turn for the ages before passing perfectly to Castagna who leaps and marks with great courage between two Giants and a giant Tiger.  It’s very similar to his mark against Geelong from Bolton’s pass, but this time he fluffs his lines and kicks another point.  It doesn’t matter because Pickett’s Blind Turn will be talked about forever.

Embed from Getty Images

And in quick time Vlaustin wins the footy on the back flank, gets it to Castagna who gives it to Pickett who goes on a little run before kicking into the 50.  He looks like he plays in a GF every week, because he does.  Well, this week and last week at least.

Dusty has a couple of opponents as he gathers the ball but it doesn’t matter.  He needs a bit of room and he finds it and dribbles the ball in for another goal and a huge roar and a chant of “Dusty…Dusty…Dusty” goes up around the ground and we’re starting to enjoy this.

Houli makes a massive spoil on the boundary and follows up with a big tackle.  Rioli gathers, passes to Lynch who kicks straight as an arrow from the tight angle.  We’ve kicked five in a row and lead by 26 points.  Can we keep this up?  Could we have a handy half-time lead?

Embed from Getty Images

From a stoppage Caddy kicks quickly and Riewoldt marks and goals from about 35 and we’re 29 points up.  Jack gets his third a bit later after marking easily and kicking from well outside 50.  At half-time we’re 35 up and my brother texts me “You’re home.”  I tell him not to jinx us but that I like kicking four goals to none against an interstate team in the GF.  That’s what we did to Adelaide two years ago, but only later do I realise that this time we actually kicked five.

It’s hard to imagine how much better this first half might have gone.  The Giants still have only one goal and our defenders are marking everything.  Vlaustin and Houli have been braver and tougher than ever, Toby Greene has hardly bothered us.

▰▰▰▰▰▰▰

Half-time score: Richmond 7.5.47 GWS 1.6.12

Castagna has his fourth shot on goal but misses again.  He’s having a great game but can’t buy a goal.  The Tigers hold up the Giants’ rebound and Lynch is set up with a perfect pass from Edwards but his kick is way off target.  Cotch passes to Riewoldt who flies and holds the footy, goes back and kicks a point.  The Giants can’t get past the half-way line though and Presty passes to Lynch who marks straight in front and kicks straight from 35.

I’m more relieved than happy.  There’s a little scramble on the boundary line in front of us, Rioli gets it to Dusty who kicks as he’s tackled and we’re up by eight goals.  Eight goals! The second half has barely started.

Pickett has only just got going too.  He gathers the ball in the centre square, runs between two rapidly-approaching Giants and passes perfectly to Martin.  Martin could kick it but he passes instead, back to Pickett who goals from about 30 and we erupt.  We’re nine goals up and every Tiger on the ground gets around the debutant and in the crowd we’re chanting “Marlon…Marlon…Marlon…”’

Embed from Getty Images

And then the Pride of Preston, Kane Lambert, gathers a Shedda handball and goals and we’re ten in front.  Ten!  What has happened to the fearsome Giants?

We try to get a new chant going – “We’ve got the best Toby, in this game/ We’ve got the best Toby, in this game/ And he won’t poke you in the eye!” – but there are no takers and we chant alone. We don’t care.

Next to me, watching the game through the mesh of the barrier we lean on, is a boy of six or eight.  I show his dad my biscuit tin with the ’74 Premiership team on the lid.  “Would your boy like one of these?” I ask.   His dad says, “I think he’d better have one, I was born in 1974!”  The young boy is called Jack, after Jack Dyer, and is standing up to the rigours of standing room.

Hopper gets the Giants’ second goal – their second goal of the game – with two minutes left.  Baker, who is having a very good game, fires off a handball that finds Astbury and is flattened for his troubles by the much larger Cameron.  But when you’re nine goals up the bumps don’t hurt and Baker smiles as he gets to his feet and takes the free.

In the last minute of the quarter Richmond’s pressure forces yet another turnover. Short gets it to Caddy who passes to Soldo who kicks the set shot straight and high and we’re 62 points up at the last break.

Embed from Getty Images

▰▰▰▰▰▰▰

Three-quarter time score:  Richmond 12.9.81 to GWS 2.7.19

Himmelberg kicks the first goal of the quarter which is disappointing.  My dread now is that the last quarter will turn into a junk-time snooze fest.  The Giants might get a few back, the result will be a respectable thrashing and we’ll never want to watch this quarter again.

That’s not how Richmond play though.  We break well downfield, Picket handballs to Castagna who goes on a little run and kicks another point.  It really doesn’t matter.  The Giants’ rebound is thwarted as Shedda spoils, Lynch kicks to Bolton who marks and goals and we’re over ten in front again.  People are singing the song and Pickett kicks another bomb into the 50 which bounces off Dusty’s chest for a point.

The big, old, drunk bloke who wanted to put me on Facebook, is now standing where he shouldn’t be, blocking the view of young Jack.  Jack’s dad asks him to move and he does, eventually.

Pickett goes again, to Rioli and Jack in the goal-square, the ball spills lose and Jack gathers and goals.  The quarter isn’t half gone and the flag is ours.  Can we keep up the chanting and singing to the end?

We try our Toby chant again, to no avail.  We still don’t care.

What happened to the monsters of our nightmares in this past week?  We’ve woken up in the morning and they’re nothing but fluffy toys.

They’ve kicked 3.7 for the day and they won’t score again.  Not so much as another rushed behind.

Cameron takes a grab and could easily score but a free is given to my brother, David Astbury, for a hold.  People in their tens of thousands are singing Tigerland.  Not like at the end of the prelim in ’95 when Geelong slaughtered us.  But now because we’ve won another flag and we’ve still got minutes of footy left to enjoy. 

There’s a bit of a flat spot in play before Rioli kicks well into the middle and finds Cotchin, who plays on, takes one bounce and kicks a goal from the 50.  The crowd erupts and my daughter hugs me.  Our cake is iced and Astbury takes another mark in defence and we sing the song again.  Vlaustin gathers and kicks yet another long one to the 50.  Martin collects the footy and goals and this can’t get any better, we’ll all die of happiness.

“Dusty…Dusty…Dusty…” we sing.

Embed from Getty Images

▰▰▰▰▰▰▰

The big, old drunk bloke is back in front of us and he grabs a woman sitting alone and gives her a big sloppy kiss on her face and he gives her friend, sitting a little distance away, an equally sloppy one.  They both laugh it off, because who would want to spoil this party?

He approaches the barrier we lean on and comes towards my daughter who is next to me.  I lean towards him as she leans back and I say “Fuck off!” I feel like he’s coming in for another go and I put my hand to his chest and say “No, fuck right off!” and he does, sort of, and takes up position a yard or two from us.

The moment is spoiled.  It shouldn’t end like this but it does.  From the bounce our Toby kicks long to Jack who marks, goes back and kicks his fifth.  Everyone goes nuts again and my daughter tries to join in but she’s shattered by what the big, old, drunk bloke just tried to do to her.  She sings and cheers through her tears, which are not of joy but of fear and anger.

The ball goes back to the middle and is bounced.  We don’t hear the siren but just hear the crowd erupt and see the players explode with joy and my daughter and me are in an awful dream where something horrible has ruined this special moment.

We sing the song, again and again, and people see her crying and think it’s because she’s so happy.  And I ask, do you want to go?  And she doesn’t.  But she doesn’t want to be here, either and is scared that the revolting man will come back.

Which he does, by which time we’re packing up to go, and he leans on the barrier and says “Sorry mate,” to me.  And I think I might have said “Fuck off!” again, and I hope that I did, but maybe I just ignored him.  And he drops the bit of paper I’d given him at quarter time, with my name and the Tiger Tiger Burning Bright address on it.

My daughter doesn’t know what to do.  But eventually she finds a policewoman who listens attentively and takes a statement and says it will be investigated and finishes off with “I’m glad I could help you.  You’re a good person and it’s good to help good people.  You did the right thing to tell us about this, it’s wrong what happened and women shouldn’t have to put up with this.”

By now we’ve met up with my partner and my other daughter.  The party on Swan Street is not for us.  We find a cab and are glad to get home and see our beloved Wolfie in his Tom Lynch jumper.  We watch the first half on the tape but I’m the only one still awake by half-time.

▰▰▰▰▰▰▰

Embed from Getty Images Embed from Getty Images Embed from Getty Images

Full-time score:  Richmond 17.12.114 to GWS 3.7.25

Brendan O'Reilly 01/10/2019Filed Under: front, Uncategorized

2019 Grand Final – the prelude

30/09/2019 By Brendan O'Reilly Leave a Comment

I’m as shocked as anyone that our opponents will be the Giants.  There’s a kind of relief – at least we won’t lose to Collingwood.  But an even worse kind of dread – what if we lose to the Giants?  What if we were the team that let this pampered corporate confection win their first flag?

Relief too that tickets will be easier to get than if it had been the Pies.  But I miss out on the ballot on Monday, 22 years of membership counting for nothing.  I go to the Giants’ website and learn that everyone in their ballot got a ticket and now they’re giving their members a second go.  Outrageous.  But all is fair in love and Grand Final ticketing and so I try to buy a couple of Giants’ memberships.  I might not be the only one with this bright idea though and their website doesn’t seem to work.

Later I get a message from Richmond telling me that the Giants still haven’t sold all their tickets and I might get another chance on Tuesday.  And sure enough, not long after 11 the next morning I’ve snagged a standing room ticket to the big game.  The news gets better.  Still more tickets remain and my daughter, a 7-9-year member, gets a chance and just after 2pm I get her a ticket too.  Calling her to give the good news is one of the best things I’ve done.  She can’t believe we’re both going.

A bit later, a TTBB reader offers yet another ticket and I’m wondering, at this rate, will the ground be only half full?

The standing room tickets for my daughter and me are in different bays.  But based on the 2017 experience, this won’t matter at all.  In 2017 we were told we had to stick to our bays but nobody checked and instead of standing in my terrible spot at M5 I went behind the goals at M3 and there was no checking.

▰▰▰▰▰▰▰

The week goes quickly.  Everything in the news is about the Giants’ “physical” game, the “clumsiness “of Mumford and the menace of Greene.  Personally, I’m a bit terrified. What really counts in finals is recent form and theirs has been good.  Clearly it doesn’t bother them anymore to play in front of a hostile crowd and why would it?  They play in front of one every other week.  Their form reminds me too much of ours in 2017, coming good at just the right time.

At work I’m busy after Tuesday which has been a bit of a write-off.  There was a farewell lunch and then afternoon tea and time spent buying tickets and telling the world I’d been successful.  What a healing journey this will be – my daughter couldn’t get a ticket in 2017 and it broke her heart.

I put in a big day on Thursday and colleagues wish me well for the weekend.  Everyone hates the Giants and hopes Richmond win, even the Collingwood supporters.  But everyone is a bit afraid too, although maybe not as much as I am.

▰▰▰▰▰▰▰

On Friday we leave the house on our bikes at about 6.30 and catch the 6.49 from Thornbury.  Just as we did in 2017, we alight at West Richmond for a little walk down to Punt Road.  There are only a few hundred in the queue on the northern side.  In 2017 we went in on the other side and there had been 2000 in the queue, even at 7.30.  Are Richmond members becoming complacent?  Or have many more thousands got lucky with tickets and so don’t feel the need to get to training to see their boys one last time?

But by the time we get in at 8.30 a decent crowd has built up.  We sit in the stand this time and the man next to me gets me to do a live interview for 2SM in Sydney.  The world looks beautiful from up here and we say we’ll come and watch some VFL and some women’s games next year.

Eventually our boys run out and do some impressive drills and stretches.  I’m not thrilled with how Cotch looks, but I don’t say anything.  I never seem to see him running and I wonder what injury he might be carrying.  Everyone else looks pretty good though.

After half an hour they depart and so do we.  In Yarra Park there are thousands of people and we find some food, but no coffee.  After we eat, we go for coffee at a place on Wellington Parade which is under siege from the Yellow and Black and the odd Orange and Grey.  We wait a good while for a coffee but everyone is patient.

In 2017, after the last training session, we made a big mistake and sought food in the city.  By the time we got out the crowds lining the parade route were ten people deep and we couldn’t see a thing.  This time we find a good spot on the corner of the Fitzroy Gardens.  It suddenly hits me what a wonderful public holiday this is.  The road is empty of traffic and all that remains is people in their teeming thousands, enjoying each other’s company.

Eventually the parade comes along and it’s the most beautiful, daggy thing I’ve ever seen.  First come some coppers on push-bikes – not in fancy dress or anything, just riding their bikes, as is their job.  Then a magnificent pipe band – I would go anywhere to listen to the bagpipes.  And a brass band playing their theme song and ours (and the Giants do have a good song, credit where it’s due) and people on stilts in fat suits and people in fat footy suits, one of which has deflated and hangs about him like a misshapen cape.

And finally, the utes, emblazoned with Toyota mottos – even this commercialism is low-key – and the umps come first and then our players, two in each ute, many with kids on laps.  And we clap and cheer as they go by. The Giants come next and the Richmond people around us are so taken with the happy atmosphere that they even clap these evil bastards.  “They’ve done well, they’ve made a Grand Final,” one yellow-and-black clad woman says as she claps them.

We train and bike home and get the washing in before it rains.  Then I go out again to the Preston Market.  It’s only five days since I last went and it’s surprising how much stuff we need.  Ray and Pat greet me warmly at their stall.  They barrack for Carlton but have known Presti’s family for years and feel a bit invested in Richmond.  They are thrilled that my daughter and I have tickets.  Like everyone else they wish me well but think it will be a tough, hard game.

▰▰▰▰▰▰▰

Nobody can believe they’ve picked Pickett for his first game.  I assume they know what they’re doing, but really?  Is this a good idea?  When you could have picked premiership players like MacIntosh or Townsend?  The man at the organic stall says it’s a good decision.  “It’s good coaching.  It’s telling them all, this is just a game of footy, just go out there and play.” I suppose there’s a logic to that.

And underneath my fear and dread there’s a faint spark of hope – if they’ve picked him for his first game, he must be more than good, they must think he’s a bit special.  Maybe he is.

▰▰▰▰▰▰▰

I get everything we need and the evening goes by in a rush.  I make a double batch of Anzacs to put in my 1974 Premiers bickie tin, make a couple of rolls for lunch, make sure the water bottles are handy, check and check again – wallet, keys, hat, tickets.  I tumble into bed after 11 and jump up with the alarm before five.

My daughter hates getting up in the morning but she’s up by six on the Friday for training and today for the game itself. I have offered to go in early and save her a spot in standing room but she won’t hear of it.  “I want to be there early too, I want to be a part of it.” And, as it turns out, it’s lucky that she is.

We’re out of the house by 6.25.  I don’t stop and check my pack on the way, because I did so just before we left – bickies, rolls, hats, wallet, keys, phones, tickets – and we’re at Thornbury a few minutes before the train comes.  At Jolimont the Members’ queue is impressive but not quite as long, I think, as in 2017.  At our gates – 6 and 7 – nobody is waiting, so we’re first in line.  I need the toilet and soon I want a coffee but neither thing is convenient.  It’s cold and I do some lunges and stair climbing to keep warm and we do the quiz in the record and don’t go too badly.  We tackle a cryptic crossword and solve a few clues but I’m too nervous to concentrate for long.

My daughter tries to teach me a clapping game and that fills in some time.  We begin to worry about our tickets, which have different gate numbers on them.  Mine says 6 and hers is 7.  My bay is M23 and hers is M26.  But I’ve been thinking all along that we’ll ignore them altogether and head down to the Punt Road End.  I do some reconnaissance and learn that M23 is a disaster.  It’s one of those standing room “bays” that isn’t a bay at all. It’s just a section of concourse that has a barrier in front of it. Unless you are right at the front, or very tall, you won’t see a thing.  Worse, there’s nowhere to sit but flush on the floor in the five hours from when you get in to when the game starts.

M26 is more promising – it’s an actual bay with steps.  A better view for everyone and a step to sit on in those long hours.  So we decide to move up to gate 7, where there are still only a few in the queue, and head to M26.  And my daughter chooses to take the bag and be in the bag-checking line while I go in the fast lane for those without bags.

This plan work well, at first.  In I go and head to M26.  I accidentally land in M25, which is fine and I think it will suit us.  However, a staff member is onto me straight away – “Can I see your ticket?  You’re not meant to be here.  This is M25.”   I go one bay over, by which time my daughter has arrived and more trouble awaits us.  They are being completely hard-arsed about standing room this year.  They are not letting you into a bay without a wrist-band and not giving you a wrist-band unless you have a ticket for that bay.  The staff won’t move on this.

Somehow, I get into the bay anyway and we park our pack and claim our spot and try to negotiate.  I explain that we’ve waited two hours to get in, we were first in line and we simply have to stand together.  They say they appreciate this but they can’t give me a wrist-band if I don’t have a ticket for this bay.  I ask to see their supervisor but they can’t find him. Eventually the man called Luke says, “I can’t give you a wrist-band.  You’ll have to try and swap your ticket for someone who’s on their own and doesn’t mind standing in M23.”  This seems like an unlikely event.  But in the meantime, I can stay with my daughter and they’ll even let me out and back in again when I need to go to the toilet.  Which is right now.

I can’t believe the bloody-mindedness of it and I’m almost crushed by the unfairness.  In front of us are the AFL members, generally a bit more nicely-dressed than us, thousands of whom don’t even barrack for Richmond, all in their very good seats.  And my daughter and I can’t even stand together?  And I don’t even get a step to stand on?

But there’s no point dwelling on it. What counts is survival.  And I can see what the staff have done – they’ve covered themselves while letting me stay.  And my daughter and I begin to relax.

▰▰▰▰▰▰▰

Five hours goes by quickly.  A couple of coffees, a few trips to the toilet, an Anzac or two, some VCE Philosophy, a phone call to Mum whom I was meant to visit this weekend.  I had planned to write pages and I barely jot a line or two.

At 1.30 when I make my last toilet trip the bay has filled up.  I’m still allowed back in and I think I’m right for the game now.  We are right at the front and our view is magnificent, near the pocket at the City End.  There is some awful pre-match entertainment, including an attempt at the “World Record Crowd Noise” (brought to you by the people who have killed crowd noise).  We don’t take part and the attempt fails.  And even worse than this, “Kiss Cam” where the camera pans the crowd and zooms in on couples – or people sitting next to each other who might, possibly, be couples – and the spruiker who should be in prison urges them to kiss. What kind of sexual harassment shit is this?

Then the live music starts, which isn’t great, except for Paul Kelly who is.  Then Up There Cazaly which goes a lot better than Williamson singing Waltzing Mathilda and then the banners go up and ours is distressingly bad – something like “add another to the collection.” A bland and complacent banner if ever we saw one.  Then the anthem and then the game.

Our nerves are totally stuffed by now.  We’re tired as hell and close to losing it.  A good close game of footy is the last thing we want.

Brendan O'Reilly 30/09/2019Filed Under: front, Uncategorized

Preliminary Final Richmond v Geelong at the MCG

23/09/2019 By Brendan O'Reilly 1 Comment

7.50pm Friday 20 September 2019 MCG On Monday, when prelim tickets go on sale, I’m on the work computer at 9am, seeking “best available” tickets for my daughter and me. Work is very busy and I can’t stuff around looking for the best seats on Level 4. I’m rewarded with bloody good seats in good time – M12, bottom deck, eight rows from the fence. The weather forecast though, is terrible and these seats are in the open. It’s going to bucket down on Friday, especially in the afternoon and at night. That will be all right though. We’ll just get to the ground early and get good spots in standing room, under cover. We’ll have a paid a fortune just to stand up, but that’s how it goes. Should we make the GF I might not get a ticket and my daughter isn’t even in the ballot. So, the prelim is our big game and surely worth the money.

Embed from Getty Images

7.50pm Friday 20 September 2019
MCG
On Monday, when prelim tickets go on sale, I’m on the work computer at 9am, seeking “best available” tickets for my daughter and me. Work is very busy and I can’t stuff around looking for the best seats on Level 4. I’m rewarded with bloody good seats in good time – M12, bottom deck, eight rows from the fence.

The weather forecast though, is terrible and these seats are in the open. It’s going to bucket down on Friday, especially in the afternoon and at night. That will be all right though. We’ll just get to the ground early and get good spots in standing room, under cover. We’ll have a paid a fortune just to stand up, but that’s how it goes. Should we make the GF I might not get a ticket and my daughter isn’t even in the ballot. So, the prelim is our big game and surely worth the money.

And by Thursday the forecast has improved out of sight – there will be no rain until Saturday.

Embed from Getty Images

It’s a tough week at work and I’m exhausted by Thursday. The Climate Strike is on Friday and I think I will go and then I think I’m too busy and that I can’t. But on the 6.06 Hurstbridge train on Friday morning I read about the world-wide day of action and decide I have to be a part of it. And at work I’m efficient and ruthless and I get everything done that I really need to and I catch the 2.01 to Jolimont. I’ve got three days off now, the sun is shining, the breeze is warm and I join a huge crowd of the young and the old in the Treasury Gardens and the very sight of their sprawling mass and the great sound of their chanting and cheering makes me weep.

I’ve had my bike on the train and when the rally breaks up, I ride home, uphill and into the wind. I’m at home a bit after five and step into dog vomit just inside the door. I spread it up the hallway before I realise what I’ve done. Nothing for it then but to de-boot, glove-up and scrub that floor clean. It doesn’t take too long. The dog, Wolfie, appears to be perfectly well and I’m glad he hasn’t spewed on someone’s bed.
Embed from Getty Images

My daughter – the Richmond supporter – doesn’t have a phone and isn’t at home yet. She’s in year 12 and has had a tough last week of term. But like our boys hope to do tonight, she’s finished strongly. But where is she? I have a feeling I will be going to the footy alone, with an expensive, spare ticket in my pocket. But using a seldom-used bit of technology known as an APP – A phriend’s phone – she calls before six and we arrange to meet at Betty Cuthbert at seven.

I charge out of the house with a hastily packed bag, wearing two scarves and lugging my daughter’s duffle coat, a good bit after six. I run half the way to the tram stop which is just as well as a tram comes very soon. On my phone I check the train times and decide to alight after two stops and leg it to Thornbury Station. There’s a train at 6.31 and my own calculations tell me that it will get to Jolimont at about ten to seven.

It’s crowded, mostly with Richmond supporters. At Jolimont we all get off and I find my daughter at Betty Cuthbert’s feet, reading the Record. The lines move quickly, even the bag-checking line, and we’re in the ground in no time. When we played the Cats in the Qualifier in 2017 those lines were endless. Maybe we’re a bit earlier tonight.

My daughter asks if we’re standing up. No, I say, sitting. In quite good seats. She can’t believe how good they actually are, about 60 metres from the goals at the Punt Road End. But you pay a price, greater than dollars, for these seats. Our fellow Richmond supporters are almost silent. They are happy to bag the umpires and boo the opposition, but that’s about it. They won’t break into a chant to save their lives. And it must be true, as I read on the train this very morning, that the richer you are the less you connect to other people. The music is as loud and obscene as ever, but Nirvana’s song seems very apt – “Here we are now, entertain us…” My fellow supporters have parted with their hard-earned and expect the Tigers to deliver them a Grand Final. They won’t help cheer and sing them over the line though. Oh no. They’ve paid their money and expect a return, no further effort on their part is required.
First Quarter

Cotchin wins the toss and chooses the Punt Road End, which is unusual. Usually he likes to kick to the City End first. But there’s a good breeze blowing outside the ground, toward the City End, and maybe he wants to come home with the wind. His choice makes us nervous and we can’t help but think of the qualifier against Port in 2014.

Embed from Getty Images

Early in the game Ellis makes a great spoil on the half-back flank and I’m glad he’s in the side and intends to stay there. Then Cotch gets it to George who misses from not too far out. A bit later Riewoldt fumbles, Geelong rebound and Ratugolea takes a huge mark on the wing. He is one Geelong player who is truly frightening. With three minutes gone Ablett scores at the Punt Road End. It’s a goal but there’s a long score review before the match can continue.
I preferred the old system of trusting the goal umpires and then bagging them all week when they got it wrong. That seemed to work for everyone.

Geelong are on top and I don’t like it and there is much moaning in M12. But then Richmond attack, Rioli kicks to Martin who runs back, marks and goals and we all feel better.
Embed from Getty Images
Graham makes a great break from the middle, kicks to Lynch who marks and kicks the goal from 48 meters. His kick is high and straight and aren’t we glad we picked up this feller?
Embed from Getty Images

Dusty goes off the ground for some reason, Soldo taps the ball to Presty who kicks it long to the goal-square. How short the ground seems when players run straight out of the middle and bomb it long. And when you have Lynch in the goal-square who can fumble the mark but kick the goal anyway. Tigers lead 3.1 to 1.0 and it’s going to be our night.

Ratugolea out-marks Toby but misses from 45 out. I love Toby to pieces but he seems to be shorter, lighter and slower than Ratugolea. But then, most people are. Presty, who is already having a great game, kicks it to Caddy who marks but kicks a point. Geelong attack in a very controlled, relentless fashion, all skill and possession and clean marking – I mean, who needs it? Eventually they go long and direct, Grimes spoils but Kelly snaps and goals from 45 out and they’re back in it.

Embed from Getty Images
Graham has come off the ground and one of the blokes in front of us, who is wired for sound, says he’s dislocated his shoulder. This is terrible news. This is going to be a tough game and he’s one of our toughest players. He won’t be doing any more tackling tonight.
The Cats attack again, Grimes tries to clear but Miers scores and it’s three goals each and the Cats have the momentum and their supporters, whom we clearly outnumber, are making a great noise. They actually seem to have some good chants going, something like “Geelong – kick it long!” Even when we had our three goals in a few minutes M12 was almost silent. The whingeing when Geelong are doing well is much louder than the cheering when it’s going our way. What does that say about people?’

Soldo takes a great mark in defence and the Tigers make a fast break but in the middle of the ground Ellis hands the ball to Toohey, which is a mistake. We win the ball back, Riewoldt marks on the forward flank, kicks short to Cotch who is tackled and is holding the ball. We’ve made some basic mistakes and our game might be unravelling. To underline this, Geelong get another through Miers who appears to be doing as he pleases. The siren goes with Geelong a goal up and well and truly on top.

Quarter time score: Richmond 3.3 – Geelong 4.3

▰▰▰▰▰▰▰

At the very start of the second term Kelly goals from 45 out and Geelong are two goals up and we look a bit hopeless. Guthrie evades two tacklers in the middle of the ground, Blicavs wins a holding-the-ball free against Lambert, but misses an easy shot. Unlike their massacre of us in round 12, the Cats are actually missing a few shots. But they are still killing us. They seem to be winning the ball more and doing smarter stuff with it.

Vlaustin turns over the footy in the back-line but Selwood misses the easy chance this affords him. Bad luck Joel. Geelong have had 16 out of the last 18 inside 50s. But Graham has reappeared on the bench with his shoulder taped up. We’re still under siege though and Lambert is lucky not to be pinged for deliberate when he goes over the line as he’s tackled.

Embed from Getty Images

Geelong attack again and Miers wins a very soft free for in-the-back against Baker, who is smaller and much lighter than him. If such a little bloke can push you around what are doing playing AFL?

Richmond finally launch an attack but Bolton misses quite an easy snap. We’re looking a bit better than we were. Graham is back on but evidently has only one arm. We clear the ball well from defence, Cotch completely outwits Ablett on the boundary and soccers it beautifully to Ellis who kicks to Martin who marks but misses from close range. We really needed that one.
Embed from Getty Images

Geelong rebound from defence and Narkle scores easily and this looks like one of those nights. Geelong are 19 points up. Nothing works for us, everything goes right for them. Cotchin is limping and the whingeing and moaning in M12 is insufferable.

Richmond attack well but Lambert’s kick goes down the throat of Kolodjashnij. Another good attack results in Martin giving the footy away after a great run down the wing. Broad is doing well and makes a great spoil against Ratugolea in the forward pocket. The Tigers rebound and Houli, who is having a good game, kicks perfectly to Castagna, 30 from goal. There is much grizzling in M12 about what a dud set-shot for goal George is. But he goes back and kicks it. It’s a goal we really, really needed but if you think that would fire up M12 you’d be wrong. People barely clap.
Embed from Getty Images

Richmond are definitely looking better but Grimes’ clearing kick is marked by Stewart who sends it straight back in. It sails over a pack of players, from the front of which Dangerfield dives like Dan from Sea Change. The umpire calls “Push!” but doesn’t say whose ball it is. Houli assumes it is his, as he actually had some physical contact from an opponent. Cotch gives him the footy but the umpire says, no, it’s a Geelong free and now it’s 50. So, Danger is gifted a goal.

I hate to criticise the umpires. I umpired a game once when I was eight and I’ve never gotten over the trauma. But this is a stinker of a decision. The umpire never said whose footy it was. So how can it be wrong to give the ball to a Richmond player?
So, plenty to sook about at half time. After we were looking a bit better, we are now 21 points down again. It could be a lot more if Geelong had kicked straight, but we missed some sitters too, so it might be less.

Half-time score: Richmond 4.5 to Geelong 7.8

▰▰▰▰▰▰▰

My daughter and I decide that we really don’t like our fellow Tiger supporters in M12. They have paid all this money and all they do is whinge. They never join in a chant and every mistake by an umpire is worth ten minutes of moaning, even while play goes on and even if Richmond might be doing well. And the man next to my daughter called the umpire a faggot and his girlfriend called someone retarded and this is what “Best available” seating gets you.

We don’t know what to do. My daughter suggests making eye contact with a few people and asking them nicely to be “chant buds.” Get a few going and the rest will follow. But I don’t have the nerve and so we go into the second half without a plan to make things better.
The Tigers, however, do have a plan. From the first bounce they attack with fury and skill. Cotch lays a big tackle in the square, Prestia gets the footy and kicks long to Lynch who marks and goals from 30 out and we can say, “We couldn’t have started any better.” It’s been so quick that our fellow supporters have almost nothing to whinge about and I’m out of my seat and in the aisle with my back to the ground, shouting and waving my arms. “Richmond! Richmond! Richmond!” And this is all it takes. In every row of seats a few people join in. Still a minority, but what a happy crowd we are. “Oh, so this is what you can do at the footy,” they seem to be thinking.

By the time I sit down again I’m faint with the effort, but it’s been worth it. And clearly our boys are appreciating this extra bit of barracking because they go in a bit harder and force a Geelong clearing kick out on the full. Martin gets the footy and kicks it high to Lynch who out-marks two defenders but misses the easy set shot. As Geelong rebound, Houli gathers the ball in the middle, handpasses to Short who evades two Geelong players and kicks deep into the forward line. Lynch can’t mark it but Martin crumbs the spilled ball and goals and we’ve got two in two minutes and are only eight points down.

Embed from Getty Images

And I’m in the aisle again, shouting and clapping and getting people going again until I’m too faint to stand up. And what a difference it’s made. People are joining in all over the place, still a minority, but a bloody noisy one. Who knew that this was all it took?

Embed from Getty Images

We are getting even better though. With only a second to put the ball on his boot, Bolton passes perfectly to Castagna. He finds the exact spot between two big Cats that George bravely flies into, with no thought for his safety. He holds the mark, of course, and nails the set-shot, of course, and there’s only a point in it. And I’m out in the aisle again, shouting and waving my arms again and heaps of people are joining in, and isn’t this fun when we’re playing well and you actually feel like you’re a part of it?

With six minutes left in the quarter Lynch puts us in front with his fourth goal. The build-up to this is magnificent, an endless series of pressure acts and tackles and a simple refusal to let Geelong clear the footy. Eventually Narkle almost breaks free but runs into The Great Wall of Cotch. The ball spills loose, Baker gets it to Shedda who kicks it to Caddy in a bit of space near the boundary. Caddy gathers calmly and passes to Presti in the pocket who centres the ball to Lynch. The big feller flies against four opponents, is held onto but marks anyway. He kicks the goal from fifteen out and we’re in front and going nuts, even in M12.

But I need to note that the glass-half-empty trio in front of us are booing the umpire even as Lynch lines up his set shot.

Embed from Getty Images

But it’s not all going our way. The ball is kicked into our backline, players go down and Miers wins a free. Broad is on the ground, concussed, and is helped from the ground by the overworked trainers. Our luck really has turned though and Miers misses.
The ball is on the wing at the bottom of a pack with Martin on top of it. Somehow, he gets out from under a great pile of Cats and brings the footy with him. I could watch this reply fifty times but I could never explain how this is possible. He gets the ball to Castagna who passes to Lynch who kicks to Prestia who marks a good distance out. In the face of the relentless Tiger pressure the Cats should have conceded a fifty but the umpire hasn’t noticed. It doesn’t matter because Prestia kicks a booming goal from 48 meters and we’re up by 10 points.

As a footnote to this, after Martin’s Contested Possession for the Ages, he finds himself tackled over the boundary line, near the interchange bench, so he just gets up, walks a few steps to the bench and sits down. Job done.

Half an hour ago it all looked pretty hopeless and I was making mental health care plans for myself for the next few weeks. Now we’re roaring and I think there’s just more good stuff to come. But Henderson marks and goals for the Cats just before the break and they’re back within a goal.

Is this the start of their fightback or a mere blip against our run?
Three-quarter time score: Richmond 9.7 – Geelong 8.9

▰▰▰▰▰▰▰

The last quarter begins well. Prestia wins a free kick in the middle and kicks it long. A pack flies, Shedda crumbs it, kicks perfectly to Lambert who marks, runs into an open goal and scores. Tim Kelly, who hasn’t gone away, gets one back for the Cats and it seems like they still want to make a fight of it. Ablett has a chance to put them back in front after out-marking Baker, but he misses.

Embed from Getty Images

Geelong attack again but Ellis wins the footy just outside the defensive 50, gets it to Houli who give it to Prestia who gives it to Caddy. Caddy kicks long to Lynch who marks almost un-opposed and kicks his fifth and were up by 11 points again. And after each of our goals I’m out in the aisle again and M12 are making some noise. And then I’m sitting down again before I fall over with light-headedness.

Riewoldt marks on the boundary, kicks and celebrates and the Tiger crowd at the City End go up with him and I’m out in the aisle again and shouting and waving my arms to an un-moved audience. “It wasn’t a goal mate,” someone says, and I skulk back to my seat.

Soldo takes a great mark in defence and has been having a very good night. With six and a half minutes left Jack Graham has a chance to win the game for us but misses on the run. It doesn’t matter, because not long after Bolton grabs the footy and handpasses to Prestia who goals from 40 out. We’re three goals up and there’s five minutes left and we’ve kicked 8.6 to 2.3 since half-time.
Riewoldt wins a holding-the-ball free kick but misses and we’re up by 19. Geelong get another point when Lachie Henderson helpfully touches a kick that would have been a goal. At the very end Castagna has a set shot that doesn’t miss by much and we’ve won by 19.

We scream and roar and sing the song, even the naysayers and the whingers in front of us sing it. And people high-five strangers and say, see you next week, if only that could be true.

Embed from Getty Images

On the telly, Hawkins looks so sad that I feel sorry for him. On the field he’s a giant I want slain, in the coach’s box he’s just a fellow human who’s stuffed up and paid a great price.

Winners can afford such generous thoughts.

Embed from Getty Images

This has been the night of nights. From so far behind and playing so badly to right in front a quarter later. And then such a strong finish. We’ve won 11 games in a row since the bye and we’ve beaten the Cats in a final, again. And we’re in a Grand Final, apparently, against Collingwood or the Giants and maybe we could even win that too.

Embed from Getty Images

I sing the song as we leave but nobody joins in. And our crowd is very different to 2017. We left the prelim that night and everyone – everyone! – was glowing like new parents. Smiling from ear to ear, bursting into song all over the place. Not tonight though. There seems to be a feeling of, “Well what else do you expect?” On the crowded train home there is no bursting into song, like the carriage-full of strangers did in 2017. People are just chatting quietly and looking at their phones and, I know we all follow our own path, but I think we should be a bit happier and celebratory.
It’s not every night you get into a Grand Final.

It’s not every night you pay Geelong back, just a little bit, for the Waverley Massacre in the ’95 prelim.

Embed from Getty Images

We walk home from Thornbury Station full of love and dis-belief. My partner and daughter are in bed but Wolfie greets us and brings out his toy to show how happy he is that we’re home. I make my daughter a cup of tea and I pour myself a beer and we watch the second half on the tape and it’s no more believable on the telly than it was at the ground.

Best players: Lynch, Houli, Prestia, Martin, Edwards, Grimes, Vlaustin, Baker, Soldo. Can I name the whole team? Everyone has done their job. Bolton didn’t have a great game but several of his kicks and touches were gold. Ellis has been great. Broad was great before he was knocked out. Graham, as Dimma says at the presser, will have a chapter written about him in the history of the club. Castagna has been very good too, marking heroically against much bigger opponents and kicking calmly under pressure.

I just love the way this team plays and I love how hard it is to pick our best players. And I love how we’ve passed every test since the bye, since Geelong and Adelaide flogged us in early June.
But there’s still one game to go. I’ve missed out on the ballot, but have another chance to buy a ticket tomorrow. I’ve tried and failed to get a Giants membership this morning, but I seem to be not the only one trying that trick at the moment.
Embed from Getty Images

▰▰▰▰▰▰▰

Benny Votes

Lynch 5, Houli 4, Prestia 3, Martin 2, Edwards 1

Leaderboard

Martin 52
Houli 49
Vlastuin 37
Lynch 33
Grimes 31
Edwards 29
Prestia 26
Stack 18
Lambert 17
Ellis 13
Cotchin, Bolton 7
Castagna, Soldo 6
Nankervis, Graham 5
Baker, Broad 4
Chol 3
Astbury, Ross, Naish 2
Rioli, Balta 1


Blair Hartley Appreciation Award: for players who have joined Richmond from another club
(Eligible 2019: Caddy, Grigg, Houli, Lynch, Nankervis, Prestia, Townsend and Weller)
Houli 49
Lynch 33
Prestia 26
Nankervis 5

Anthony Banik Best First Year Player: for anyone who was yet to debut before round 1
(Eligible 2019: Balta, Coleman-Jones, Collier-Dawkins, Miller, Naish, Ross, Turner, Stack)
Stack 18
Ross, Naish 2
Balta 1

Joel Bowden’s Golden Left Boot:for left footers
(Eligible 2019: Chol, Grigg, Nankervis and Houli)
Houli 49
Nankervis 5
Chol 3

Greg Tivendale Rookie List Medal:
upgraded from the rookie list during the current season
(Potentially eligible 2019: Aarts, Baker, Chol, Eggmolesse-Smith, Stack, Townsend, Weller)
Stack 18
Baker 4
Chol 3

Maurice Rioli Grip of Death Trophy:
For the Tiges top tackler in 2019

Prestia 120
Graham 113
Castagna 75
Edwards 69
Lambert 67
Vlastuin 66
Baker, Bolton 61

Embed from Getty Images

Brendan O'Reilly 23/09/2019Filed Under: benny, front, Uncategorized

Qualifying Final Brisbane v Richmond at The Gabba

11/09/2019 By Brendan O'Reilly 2 Comments

Saturday 8 September 2019 7.25pm. People keep asking me if I’m nervous about the footy but I’m not until late on Saturday afternoon. We’re a different team and a different club to the one that ventured to the Gabba in 2001 and got shredded by the Lions or the one whose heroic winning streak hit a brick against Port in Adelaide in 2014. But the fact is, we’ve never won an interstate final. Also, at least twice that I know of, we’ve played in the first week of the finals the team we had just beaten in the last home and away round. And we lost both of them. This was to the Bombers in 2001 and North in 2015. The simple fact is that both teams tanked those home and away games. Essendon with some subtlety in 2001 and North without shame in 2015.

Embed from Getty Images

People keep asking me if I’m nervous about the footy but I’m not until late on Saturday afternoon. We’re a different team and a different club to the one that ventured to the Gabba in 2001 and got shredded by the Lions or the one whose heroic winning streak hit a brick against Port in Adelaide in 2014. But the fact is, we’ve never won an interstate final.

Also, at least twice that I know of, we’ve played in the first week of the finals the team we had just beaten in the last home and away round. And we lost both of them. This was to the Bombers in 2001 and North in 2015. The simple fact is that both teams tanked those home and away games. Essendon with some subtlety in 2001 and North without shame in 2015.
Yes, things are different now. But still…

I spend two hours cooking an excellent dinner which I hope we can enjoy like civilised people at the table before the footy. But in fact, it’s not ready until bang on 7.25 so we eat on the couch. Roasted veg, pork and fennel sausages, flathead fillets and, for my Richmond-barracking daughter, a simple potato and cauli fritter that I whipped up right at the end. My plate is piled with food but the nerves have kicked in and I’ve never felt less hungry in my life.

▰▰▰▰▰▰▰

I’m glad that we kick the first two goals because, despite the many Tiger fans at the ground, this sounds like a real interstate final with a hostile crowd. They seem to boo everything any of our players do. And I’m worried about the weather too. My phone told me it was 27 degrees before the game started and this will surely make it hard for our boys to run the game out.

Riewoldt kicks the first from the 50 after winning a holding-the-ball free. It’s true that his opponent had almost no prior opportunity but nobody does these days and the commentators make more of this than I want. Speaking of the commentators, they include Darcy whom I can’t abide. In the opening minutes he makes a reference to Grimes’ reputation “…around the industry…” The industry! Why do we let Marketing Departments tell us how to speak?

Shedda makes a great snap for goal number two and maybe this will be our night? Maybe we’ll crush the Lions early and silence the crowd and hold them at arms-length for the rest of the game?

It’s not to be though. Brisbane attack and attack again and we can’t seem to break clear. They have five points on the board in no time and we’re very lucky that they can’t kick straight. Then they have their first goal and the crowd goes off and then their second and they’re in front and then two more before the first break and we’re on the ropes.

Quarter time score: Brisbane 4.6.30 to Richmond 3.0.18

▰▰▰▰▰▰▰

The second term begins well when Caddy takes the ball from the middle and finds Cotch who out-marks Hodge in the pocket. But our captain misses from an angle and we have our first point of the night. Maybe things aren’t going to go our way? Riewoldt makes a great attempt at a high mark and the ball spills loose and one of our brilliant crumbers will surely kick a goal. But no, a free kick is awarded against Riewoldt for in-the-back which is simply ridiculous.

Lynch takes what I count as his third mark from a clearing kick but then he kicks it backwards and we turn the ball over. Someone needs to tell our players that the Wallace and Frawley kick-it-backwards-at-all-times era is over. We’re Richmond and we kick it forward!

Embed from Getty Images
Saturday 8 September 2019 7.25pm
Shai Bolton flies and holds the mark. It’s an absolute ripper but his kick is even better. It finds Lynch 15 from goal who goes back and kicks it. Suddenly we look a much better team and we’re only three points down.

Rainer is playing well for Brisbane and takes a great mark. Grimes and Cameron are having a good tussle and when Cameron helps Grimes to his feet I realise why my daughter loves Charlie so much.

Richmond attack again but Brisbane win it back and move the ball very easily into the 50 where Rayner marks but misses from 45 out. This is a big let-off for us. Darcy annoys me again by saying the Tigers are having “the rub of the green.” Maybe a bit of luck with the umpires, but Riewoldt would disagree.

Embed from Getty Images

We are lucky though with Brisbane’s kicking for goals which is terrible. Cameron gets free and snaps and misses. Hodge is doing well in defence, even though the Chanel Seven commentators say so. The Lions attack well again but Grimes takes a mark on the last line of defence and wins a 50 as well. The ball gets to Caddy who bombs it long into the 50, Lynch flies but doesn’t mark, Rioli gathers and goals and we’re two points up with seven minutes left in the quarter. The Lions have outplayed us everywhere but can’t kick straight while we don’t seem able to miss.

Rayner misses an easy one to emphasise this. Graham makes a huge tackle in the middle and wins a free but the Lions rebound again. With four minutes left McStay out-marks Vlaustin. Tigger and Houli, too, are not having their usual great games. But the luck is with us as McStay misses from right in front. The Tigers rebound quickly, Dusty is one-out in the forward line, marks and goals. We have just done to Brisbane what teams used to do to us several times a game, every game, from about 1983 to 2016.
McInerney wins a free for falling over but misses from close range. We rebound again, Dusty wins the footy, finds Bolton with a handpass and Bolton steams in with nobody near him and kicks a goal. It’s half-time and after being outplayed for most of the first term and a fair bit of the second, we’re 11 points up.

Half-time score: Brisbane 4.10.34 to Richmond 7.3.45

▰▰▰▰▰▰▰

The third term starts very well for us. Presty and Shedda combine to get the ball to Martin who wins a free for a clear hold and kicks a goal from close range. Then Shedda wins the ball again, kicks it to Rioli who ought to play on and goal but instead kicks it to Bolton who is out-marked. This is a mistake our forwards make too often – dishing off the footy instead of taking responsibility and kicking the goal themselves. Sometimes that “team-first” rubbish can really hurt you. But I’m being very picky, we’re three goals up in the third term in an interstate final and I just need something to worry about.

Shedda is having a huge game. The quarter isn’t half over and he’s had 14 contested possessions. With Martin in the forward line he’s running the midfield like he owns it. We attack again and this time Rioli hogs the footy, as he should, while Botlon keeps the Brisbane defender away from him. Young Dan bounces and almost loses the footy, but gets it back, has another bounce and goals from close range and we’re four goals up and this is starting to feel very good.

Not long after this Rioli snaps again but misses. Then Riewoldt taps a boundary throw-in to Dusty who runs in and goals again. It’s his fourth and he’s unstoppable and Richmond are five goals in front.

Bolton picks up the footy and kicks it out on the full, proving that not everything we do is perfect, but at least not adding to our measly total of behinds. The commentator, Mark Soderstrom, is still calling him “Shy” Bolton, although it is fairly well-known that his name is pronounced “Shay,” as in Guevara. My daughter points out, “It’s his frickin’ job to know how to say players’ names!”

Things really are going our way. Hodge, who is having a very good game, kicks out-on-the-full and Lynch marks the resulting free without too much trouble and kicks the goal. We’re six goals up and have kicked eight in a row. The Lions last goal was in the first quarter but they’ve added a bundle of behinds since then.

Embed from Getty Images

Shedda takes a massive, very brave mark, running back and leaping with the flight of the footy. He gets it to Caddy who kicks a goal from the 50 and we’re 41 points up. My other daughter and my partner dish up a pear and blueberry galette with ice-cream and we are living the life.

McCluggage, whose name I can’t quite believe, gets one for the Lions and then Shedda takes another great mark. We break-away down the field, Caddy runs along the wing, gets it to Bolton who finds Castagna who snaps and goals from 40 out. Then Dusty gets his fifth and we’re 46 points up and I’m starting to believe that we’ll probably win and daring to admit that I’m actually enjoying this.

Vlaustin helps Cameron to his feet after a contest and I’ve always loved Tigger. This gentlemanly conduct might have to stop as Christensen gets Brisbane’s second goal of the quarter just before the siren and we’re 38 points up at the last break.

From memory, this is what we trailed the Lions by at half-time in the prelim in 2001.

Three-quarter time score: Brisbane 6.14.50 to Richmond 14.4.88

▰▰▰▰▰▰▰

My partner, bless her, has come up with a great nick-name for Grimes – The Cleaner. D-Grimes = The Cleaner. Which describes his game completely, he just cleans up.

Brisbane start the last term as they have played all night. McCarthy out-marks Baker but misses from 20 out with not much angle and they now have 6.15 for their night’s work. Rioli goes down and looks to have a problem with his ankle, then he’s off the ground and the doctor is taking a look.

Caddy gives away a 50 for some reason on our forward 50 and McCluggage marks in the Brisbane forward line and misses. Rioli’s ankle is being bandaged, there’s 13 left in the term and we’re six goals up. I’m not relaxed about the result. If Brisbane ever work out that they should kick between the big sticks they could have six goals in no time. I want us to kick two more to finish them off. Then Riewoldt kicks one and I feel safe. It should never have been a goal – Dusty blatantly threw it to him, scooping the ball off the ground, but he got away with it.

Maybe we have been lucky tonight.

Lachie Neale, who has been good, if not quite as busy as last week, gets a goal for the Lions but the match seems to be over. The crowd is 37,478, which is a record footy crowd for the Gabba. Brisbane kick another point and Richmond are up by 35 with 10 minutes left. Brisbane attack but Shedda takes yet another great mark in defence and sends us into attack. Dusty gathers the ball on the 50 and kicks his sixth goal and I think we might be home.

Then we win a free and a 50 in the forward line and Riewoldt kicks another and we’re 47 points up, the same as Soldo’s number. Our supporters are singing “Tigerland” and all is right with the world. Rioli is back on and makes a great tackle. We’re 47 points up, there’s seven minutes left and he’s still throwing himself into it.

Martin wins a free on the 50, the ball gets to Caddy who makes room for himself and goals and we’re 53 points up. Christensen gets one back for the Lions and only then do I realise that the Lions too have been afflicted with the electronic roar, may our respective Marketing Departments burn in hell.

The siren sounds and we’ve kicked 18.4, the second-most accurate kicking of any team in any final and the most accurate score I can remember the Tigers kicking ever. In the second half we’ve kicked 11.1 to 4.7. Our players look happy and there seems to be lots of good will between our players and theirs. I could be wrong though, victory does give one a particular view of things.

Final Score: Brisbane 8.17.65 to Richmond 18.4.112
Embed from Getty Images

▰▰▰▰▰▰▰

We’re allowed one rendition of Tigerland before a truly awful ad booms out over the ground’s PA. If I didn’t have such a malign view of marketing departments, I would swear that fascist aliens had taken over and were issuing instructions. Then a very loud ground announcer is heard and what a relief it is not to have the ends of games ruined by the singing and cheering of supporters. I can’t imagine anything worse than that.
Shedda is interviewed and is predictably modest, saying his team-mates did all the hard work on the inside to get the ball to him. This is quite a thing to say after you’ve won 18 contested footies.

It’s a great night for the Tigers. Remember that awful night in round two, our first game without Rance, when Collingwood pulled us apart? Or two weeks before the bye when Geelong humiliated us at the ‘G? (They didn’t complain about playing at the ‘G that night). Or that awful run of injuries to our best players? And now we’re in a prelim, against Geelong or West Coast, with two weeks to prepare for it.

But to keep things in perspective, we’ve been lucky. Brisbane kicked their way out of this one and had three more scoring shots than us. Especially in the first and second quarters, had they kicked straight we would have been in all sorts. And had we not kicked straight at our end, who knows?

Shedda has been magnificent, the best game I’ve seen him play and he’s played some beauties. Presty has been great in the middle too. Dusty has been quite handy in our forward line and six goals is not to be sneezed at. Soldo has been great in the ruck and, it may be blasphemous to say so, but he’s playing better than Toby. Quite often he puts the ball down the throat of his team-mates. And our defenders, despite the massive pressure they were under early in the game, have stood up. Grimes has been outstanding and Astbury has been good too. Baker and Short have been good. Houli and Vlaustin have not played their usual games but have battled away to the end.
Embed from Getty Images

▰▰▰▰▰▰▰

Benny Votes

Edwards 5, Prestia 4, Martin 3, Soldo 2, Grimes 1

Leaderboard

Martin 50
Houli 45
Vlastuin 37
Grimes 31
Edwards, Lynch 28
Prestia 23
Stack 18
Lambert 17
Ellis 13
Cotchin, Bolton 7
Castagna, Soldo 6
Nankervis, Graham 5
Baker, Broad 4
Chol 3
Astbury, Ross, Naish 2
Rioli, Balta 1


Blair Hartley Appreciation Award: for players who have joined Richmond from another club
(Eligible 2019: Caddy, Grigg, Houli, Lynch, Nankervis, Prestia, Townsend and Weller)
Houli 45
Lynch 28
Prestia 23
Nankervis 5

Anthony Banik Best First Year Player: for anyone who was yet to debut before round 1
(Eligible 2019: Balta, Coleman-Jones, Collier-Dawkins, Miller, Naish, Ross, Turner, Stack)
Stack 18
Ross, Naish 2
Balta 1

Joel Bowden’s Golden Left Boot:for left footers
(Eligible 2019: Chol, Grigg, Nankervis and Houli)
Houli 45
Nankervis 5
Chol 3

Greg Tivendale Rookie List Medal:
upgraded from the rookie list during the current season
(Potentially eligible 2019: Aarts, Baker, Chol, Eggmolesse-Smith, Stack, Townsend, Weller)
Stack 18
Baker 4
Chol 3

Maurice Rioli Grip of Death Trophy:
For the Tiges top tackler in 2019

Prestia 115
Graham 108
Castagna 74
Vlastuin 65
Bolton 61
Lambert 60
Embed from Getty Images

Brendan O'Reilly 11/09/2019Filed Under: benny, front

  • « Previous Page
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • Next Page »
The Virtual Duffle Coat
Let us know who you want to see remembered on TTBB’s duffle coat. Email or Tweet Chris and he’ll create a badge for you and your player.
© Dugald Jellie and Chris Rees 2017 | Log in